J. Stokely Fulton ODAC Offensive Player of the Year
| Name |
Year |
| Luke Heinsohn - Running Back |
2012 |
| Charlie Westfal - Quarterback |
2011 |
| Marc Watson - Running Back |
2000 |
| Kevin Weaver - Running Back |
1985 |
| Chris Cavalline - Running Back |
1981 |
| Tony Perry - Tight End |
1976 |
Lou Wacker ODAC Defensive Player of the Year
| Name |
Year |
| Jalen Todd - Linebacker |
2024 |
| David Onyejekwe - Linebacker |
2022 |
| Max Garrett - Linebacker |
2017 |
| Kyle Luby - Safety |
2007 |
| Robert Hull - Defensive Line |
1995 |
| Carl Folick - Linebacker |
1978 |
ODAC Lineman of the Year
| Name |
Year |
| Wesley Howenstein |
2025 |
ODAC Coach of the Year
| Name |
Year |
| Garrett LeRose |
2021 |
| Scott Abell |
2012, 2015, 2017 |
| Frank Miriello |
1996, 2001, 2004, 2006, 2010 |
| Gary Fallon |
1981, 1988, 1992 |
ODAC Rookie of the Year
| Name |
Year |
| Anthony Crawford - Running Back |
2023 |
| Josh Breece - Running Back |
2017 |
| Marshall Hollerith - Running Back |
2013 |
| Charlie Westfal - Quarterback |
2008 |
| Greg Kurkis - Offensive Line |
2007 |
| R.J. Varner - Quarterback |
2006 |
ODAC / Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year
| Name |
Year |
| Peyton Pack |
2023 |
| Robert Poindexter |
2022 |
| Sean Clark |
2018 |
| Max Garrett |
2016, 2017 |
| Brett Murray |
2011 |
| Greg Kurkis |
2009, 2010 |
| Liam Murray |
2005 |
D3football.com All-Region
| Name |
Year |
| Wesley Howenstein |
2025 (1) |
| Ryan Clemens |
2025 (2) |
| Will Mahmud |
2024 (3) |
| Charlie Fleming |
2024 (3) |
| Harrison Donovan |
2024 (3) |
| Tyler Halliday |
2024 (3) |
| Jalen Todd |
2024 (2) |
| Jacob Romero |
2023 (3), 2024 (2) |
| Nathan Unger |
2023 (2) |
| Jared Cordova |
2021 (2) |
| Dean Johnson |
2021 (2) |
| Robert Poindexter |
2021 (2) |
| Sean Clark |
2019 (2) |
| Mitch Hornsby |
2017 (2), 2018 (3) |
| Josh Breece |
2017 (1), 2021 (2) |
| Max Garrett |
2016 (2), 2017 (1) |
| Will Dyson |
2016 (1) |
| Chris Osier |
2015 (3), 2017 (1) |
| Raymond Monasterski |
2015 (2) |
| Michael LaSala |
2015 (1), 2016 (2) |
| Connor Hollenbeck |
2012 (2), 2013 (1) |
| Alex Evans |
2011 (2) |
| Brett Murray |
2011 (1) |
| John Fitzgibbons |
2011 (1) |
| Greg Kurkis |
2010 (3) |
| Luke Heinsohn |
2010 (2), 2012 (1) |
| Jake Pelton |
2010 (2), 2011 (1), 2012 (2) |
| Charlie Craigle |
2009 (2) |
| Matt Cassilly |
2009 (2) |
| Kyle Luby |
2007 (2) |
| Hunter Whitfield |
2006 (2) |
| Mark Snoddy |
2006 (2) |
| Jack Martin |
2005 (2) |
| Stuart Sitterson |
2005 (1) |
(1) denotes first team All-Region, (2) denotes second team All-Region, (3) denotes third team All-Region
All-America Selections
| Association |
Name |
Year |
| D3football.com (11) |
Chris Osier |
2017 (2) |
|
Josh Breece |
2017 (HM) |
|
Will Dyson |
2016 (3) |
|
Michael LaSala |
2015 (3) |
|
Connor Hollenbeck |
2013 (HM) |
|
Luke Heinsohn |
2012 (4) |
|
John Fitzgibbons |
2011 (1) |
|
Jake Pelton |
2011 (HM) |
|
Stuart Sitterson |
2005 (1) |
|
Mat Rapoza |
2001 (1), 2002 (2) |
|
| AFCA (7) |
Jalen Todd |
2024 (1) |
|
Max Garrett |
2017 (2) |
|
Michael LaSala |
2015 (1) |
|
Connor Hollenbeck |
2013 (1) |
|
Glenn Kirschner |
1983 (1) |
|
Mike Pressler |
1981 (1) |
|
Tony Perry |
1976 (1) |
|
| Associated Press (19) |
Jalen Todd |
2024 (2) |
|
Josh Breece |
2017 (2) |
|
Michael LaSala |
2015 (3) |
|
Chris Sullivan |
2001 (3) |
|
Robert Hull |
1995 (2) |
|
Carl Folcik |
1978 (HM) |
|
Jack Berry |
1975 (HM) |
|
Tony Perry |
1974 (HM) |
|
Steve Mahaffey |
1970 (HM) |
|
Jeff Novinger |
1965 (HM) |
|
Tersh Baker |
1965 (HM) |
|
John Anthony |
1965 (HM) |
|
Bill David |
1964 (HM) |
|
Bob Payne |
1961 (HM) |
|
Tommy Goodwin |
1961 (HM) |
|
Steve Suttle |
1961 (HM) |
|
Charlie Gummy |
1961 (HM) |
|
Terry Fohs |
1960 (3), 1961 (2) |
|
| Associated Press / United Press (20) |
Bill McHenry |
1952 (HM), 1953 (HM) |
|
Bob Thomas |
1951 (HM) |
|
Walt Michaels |
1950 (HM) |
|
Joe McCutcheon |
1950 (HM) |
|
Robert Conrad |
1950 (HM) |
|
Gil Bocetti |
1950 (HM), 1951 (HM) |
|
Dick Working |
1947 (HM) |
|
Bill Chipley |
1946 (HM) |
|
Robert Norman |
1942 (HM) |
|
Dick Boisseau |
1938 (HM), 1939 (HM) |
|
Jack Bailey |
1934 (HM) |
|
Sam Mattox |
1934 (HM) |
|
George Glynn |
1934 (HM) |
|
William Ellis |
1934 (HM) |
|
Amos Bolen |
1933 (HM) |
|
Wilbur Mattox |
1931 (HM) |
|
Ty Ruaber |
1926 (3) |
|
| Don Hansen Football Gazette (6) |
Stuart Sitterson |
2005 (2) |
|
Jack Mertin |
2005 (HM) |
|
Robert Hull |
1994 (2) |
|
Carter Quayle |
1988 (HM) |
|
Tom Skeen |
1988 (HM) |
|
Jim Johnson |
1988 (HM) |
|
| Hewlett Packard (5) |
Brad Wiginton |
2001 (3) |
|
Robert Hull |
1995 (1) |
|
Craig Irons |
1989 (2) |
|
Mike Pack |
1989 (HM) |
|
Phillip Sampson |
1989 (HM) |
|
| USAFootball.com (2) |
Christian Batcheller |
1999 (HM) |
|
Justin Holton |
1999 (HM) |
|
| Champion (3) |
Robert Hull |
1993 (2) |
|
Bob Ehret |
1992 (2) |
|
John McCallum |
1991 (3) |
|
| Walter Camp (1) |
Jalen Todd |
2024 |
(1) denotes first team All-America, (2) denotes second team All-America, (3) denotes third team All-America, (HM) denotes honorable mention All-America
Gagliardi Award Finalist (Division III Player of the Year)
| Name |
Year |
| Luke Heinsohn - Running Back |
2012 |
| Chris Sullivan - Running Back |
2002 |
| Robert Hull - Defensive Line |
1995 |
Willie Lanier Award (Virginia College Division Player of the Year)
| Name |
Year |
| Luke Heinsohn - Running Back |
2012 |
| Charlie Westfal - Quarterback |
2011 |
| Robert Hull - Defensive Line |
1995 |
CoSIDA / CSC Academic All-Americans
| Name |
Year |
| Andrew Frailer |
2020 (1) |
| Grey Reames |
2018 (2) |
| Max Garrett |
2018 (1) |
| Brett Murray |
2011 (2), 2012 (1) |
| Greg Kurkis |
2009 (2), 2010 (1) |
| Jay Thomas |
2001 (1) |
| Evans Edwards |
1991 (2), 1992 (2) |
| Michael Magoline |
1988 (2) |
| Richard Wiles |
1978 (2) |
| George Ballantyne |
1978 (2) |
| John Cocklereece |
1975 (1) |
| Andrew Kumpuris |
1970 (2) |
(1) denotes first team Academic All-America, (2) denotes second team Academic All-America, (3) denotes third team Academic All-America
NCAA Postgraduate Scholarship Winners
| Name |
Year |
| Andrew Frailer |
2020 |
| Greg Kurkis |
2010 |
| John Melillo |
2003 |
| Michael Magoline |
1989 |
| Lonnie Nunley |
1981 |
| Scott Smith |
1980 |
| Richard Wiles |
1979 |
| Jeffrey Slatcoff |
1978 |
| William Wallace |
1974 |
| Michael Thornton |
1970 |
National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
Total Selections (24)
| Year |
Name |
| 2026 (12) |
Greg Bafalis |
|
Dryden Duggins |
|
Ian Evans |
|
Josh Garcia |
|
Alan Haigler |
|
Malik Hardy |
|
Tucker Jacobsen |
|
Jack Johnson |
|
Will Knight |
|
Will Mahmud |
|
Fritz Nottebohm |
|
Tate Whitmer |
| 2019 (8) |
Alex Cantrell |
|
Reed Clark |
|
Nate Faber |
|
Mitch Hornsby |
|
Stephen McCaffery |
|
Reid Ostrom |
|
Patrick Ryan |
|
Collin Sherman |
| 2010 (1) |
Daniel Kohl |
| 2007 (3) |
Mark C. Snoddy |
|
Josh Hudak |
|
James Delgado |
AFCA Aztec Bowl Participants
| Name |
Year |
| Jack Martin |
2007 |
