97 Total Selections
2024-25 (8 total)
First Team – Sarah Zimmerman (Women's Soccer), Libby Ford (At-Large - Women's Lacrosse)
Second Team – Tyler Spano (At-Large - Men's Lacrosse), Hillis Burns (At-Large - Men's Lacrosse), Jonathan McEwen (At-Large - Men's Golf), Cassie Carr (Women's Cross Country, Track and Field)
Third Team – Will Joseph (Men's Soccer), John Santowski (At-Large - Wrestling)
2022-23
Second Team – Tess Muneses (At-Large – Field Hockey)
2021-22
First Team – Courtney Berry (Volleyball), Andrew Frailer (Football)
Second Team – Michael Nyc (Men's Soccer), Landon Shelley (At-Large – Women's Lacrosse)
2020
Second Team – Emily Hageboeck (At-Large – Women's Swimming), Brian Peccie (At-Large – Men's Golf)
2019
First Team – Brian Peccie (At-Large – Men's Golf)
Second Team – Hank Patrick (Men's Cross Country/Track and Field)
Third Team – Cordelia Peters (At-Large – Women's Lacrosse), Emily Hageboeck (At-Large – Women's Swimming)
2018 (9 total)
First Team – Tommy Thetford – (At-Large – Men's Swimming), Emily Perszyk (Women's Basketball), Max Garrett (Football)
Second Team – Gillen Beck (Men's Soccer), Luke Farley (At-Large Men's Golf), Nicholas George (Men's Basketball), Grey Reames (Football)
Third Team – Cordelia Peters (At-Large Women's Lacrosse), Hank Patrick (Men's Cross Country/Track and Field)
2017
First Team – Brooke Donnelly (At-Large – Women's Tennis)
Second Team – Luke Farley (At-Large – Men's Golf)
Third Team – Tommy Thetford (At-Large – Men's Swimming)
2016
First Team – Michael Holt (At-Large – Men's Tennis), Brooke Donnelly (At-Large – Women's Tennis)
Third Team – Tommy Thetford (At-Large – Men's Swimming)
2015
Third Team – Michael Holt (At-Large – Men's Tennis)
2014
Third Team – Michael Holt (At-Large – Men's Tennis), Annelise Madison (At-Large – Women's Cross Country/Track and Field)
2013
Second Team – Wayde Marsh (At-Large – Men's Swimming)
Third Team – Rick Sykes (At-Large – Men's Swimming)
2012
First Team – Sam Campbell (At-Large – Wrestling), Brett Murray (Football)
Second Team – Chris Washnock (At-Large – Men's Swimming)
2011
Second Team – Brett Murray (Football)
Third Team – Sam Campbell (At-Large – Wrestling), Chris Washnock (At-Large – Men's Swimming)
2010
First Team – Greg Kurkis (Football)
2009
Second Team – Greg Kurkis (Football)
Third Team – Katie Tabb (At-Large – Women's Tennis), Becca Taylor (Women's Cross Country/Track and Field), Elizabeth Webb (Women's Cross Country/Track and Field)
2008
First Team – Anne Van Devender (Women's Soccer)
Second Team – Greg Kurkis (Football), Nathaniel James (At-Large – Men's Golf), Tom Brower (Men's Cross Country/Track and Field)
Third Team – Becca Taylor (Women's Cross Country/Track and Field)
2007
First Team – Katie Kingsbury (At-Large – Women's Tennis)
Third Team – Ginny Wortham (At-Large – Women's Tennis)
2006
First Team – Courtney Harrison (At- Large Field Hockey)
Second Team – Nathan Johnson (Men's Cross Country/Track and Field)
2005
Second Team- Nathan Johnson (Men's Cross Country/Track and Field)
2004
Second Team – Peter Dean (Baseball)
Third Team – Eric Ritter (At-Large – Men's Swimming), Lindsay Hagerman (At-Large – Men's Swimming), Emily Wolfing (Volleyball)
2003
Second Team – Peter Dean (Baseball)
Third Team – Heather Coleman (Women's Soccer)
2002
First Team – John Melillo (Football)
2001
First Team – Jay Thomas (Football)
Third Team – Joshua Chamberlain (At-Large – Wrestling)
2000
Second Team – James Browne (At-Large – Men's Swimming)
1999
Second Team – Nancy Reinhart (Volleyball)
1997
First Team – Nathan Hottle (At-Large – Men's Swimming)
Third Team – Natalia Garcia (At-Large – Women's Tennis)
1996
First Team – Graig Fantuzzi (Baseball)
Second Team – Nathan Hottle (At-Large – Men's Swimming)
Third Team – Josephine Schaeffer (At-Large – Women's Cross Country/Track and Field)
1995
First Team – Graig Fantuzzi (Baseball)
1994
First Team – Scott Covey (At-Large – Men's Cross Country/Track and Field)
Second Team – Graig Fantuzzi (Baseball)
Third Team – Elizabeth Bahn (Volleyball), Angie Carrington (At-Large – Women's Lacrosse)
1992
First Team – Evans Edwards (Football)
1991
Second Team – Evans Edwards (Football), Michael Holton (Men's Basketball)
1990
Second Team – Teresa Southard (At-Large – Women's Tennis)
Third Team – Michael Holton (Men's Basketball)
1989
Second Team – Michael Holton (Men's Basketball)
Third Team – Eddie Klank (Baseball)
1988
Second Team – Michael Magoline (Football)
Third Team – Eddie Klank (Baseball)
1987
Second Team – Chris Talley (Baseball)
Hon. Mention – Steve Castle (At-Large – Wrestling), Andrew White (At-Large Track and Field)
1986
First Team – Larry Anker (At-Large – Wrestling)
1985
Third Team – Jeffrey Dixon (At-Large – Wrestling)
1984
First Team – Tim Valliere (At-Large – Wrestling)
Second Team – Dave Warrenfeltz (Baseball)
1982
Hon. Mention – John Lee Graves (Men's Basketball)
1978
First Team – George Ballantyne (Football)
Second Team – Richard Wiles (Second Team)
1975
First Team – John Cocklereece (Football)
1972
Second Team – Mike Daniel (Second Team)
1970
Second Team – Andrew Kumpuris (Football)
