Football All-Americans
D3football.com
2017:
Second Team – Chris Osier (Offensive Line)
Honorable Mention – Josh Breece (Running Back), Max Garrett (Linebacker)
2016:
Third Team – Will Dyson (Cornerback)
2015:
Third Team – Michael LaSala (Offensive Line)
2013:
Honorable Mention – Connor Hollenbeck (Offensive Line)
2012:
Fourth Team – Luke Heinsohn (Running Back)
2011:
First Team – John Fitzgibbons (Offensive Line)
Honorable Mention – Jake Pelton (Safety)
2005:
First Team – Stuart Sitterson (Return Specialist)
2002:
Third Team – Mat Rapoza (Offensive Line)
2001:
First Team – Mat Rapoza (Offensive Line)
American Football Coaches Associations
2017:
Second Team – Max Garrett (Linebacker)
2015:
First Team – Michael LaSala (Offensive Line)
2013:
First Team – Connor Hollenbeck (Offensive Line)
1986:
First Team – John Packett (Offensive Line)
1983:
First Team – Glenn Kirschner (Offensive Line)
1981:
First Team – Mike Pressler (Defensive Line)
1976:
First Team – Tony Perry (Tight End)
Associated Press
2017:
Second Team – Josh Breece (Running Back)
2015:
Third Team – Michael LaSala (Offensive Line)
2001:
Third Team – Chris Sullivan (All-Purpose Back)
1995:
Second Team – Robert Hull (Defensive Line)
1978:
Honorable Mention – Carl Folcik (Linebacker)
1975:
Honorable Mention – Jack Berry (Quarterback)
1974:
Honorable Mention – Tony Perry (Tight End)
1970:
Honorable Mention – Steve Mahaffey (Wide Receiver)
1965:
Honorable Mention – John Anthony (Fullback), Tersh Baker (Tight End), Jeff Novinger (Linebacker)
1964:
Honorable Mention – Bill David (Running Back)
1961:
Second Team – Terry Fohs (Offensive Line)
Honorable Mention – Charlie Gummey (Running Back), Steve Suttle (Quarterback), Tommy Goodwin (Offensive Line), Bob Payne (Offensive Line)
1960:
Third Team – Terry Fohs (Offensive Line)
Associated Press/United Press
1953:
Honorable Mention – Bill McHenry (Offensive Line)
1952:
Honorable Mention – Bill McHenry (Offensive Line)
1951:
Honorable Mention – Gil Bocetti (Quarterback), Bob Thomas (Tight End)
1950:
Honorable Mention – Gil Bocetti (Quarterback), Robert Conrad (Offensive Line), Joe McCutcheon (Offensive Line), Walt Michaels (Running Back)
1947:
Honorable Mention – Dick Working (Running Back)
1946:
Honorable Mention – Bill Chipley (Tight End)
1942:
Honorable Mention – Robert Norman (Tight End)
1939:
Honorable Mention – Dick Boisseau (Offensive Line)
1938:
Honorable Mention – Dick Boisseau (Offensive Line)
1934:
Honorable Mention – William Ellis (Running Back), George Glynn (Tight End), Sam Mattox (Running Back), Jack Bailey (Running Back)
1933:
Honorable Mention – Amos Bolen (Guard)
1931:
Honorable Mention – Wilbur Mattox (Running Back)
1926:
Third Team – Ty Rauber (Running Back)
Don Hansen Football Gazette
2005:
Second Team – Stuart Sitterson (Return Specialist)
Honorable Mention – Jack Mertin (Wide Receiver)
1994:
Second Team – Robert Hull (Defensive Line)
1988:
Honorable Mention – Jim Johnson (Defensive Line), Tom Skeen (Linebacker), Carter Quayle (Placekicker)
Hewlett Packard
2001:
Third Team – Brad Wiginton (Placekicker)
1995:
First Team – Robert Hull (Defensive Line)
1989:
Second Team – Craig Irons (Wide Receiver)
Honorable Mention – Phillip Sampson (Quarterback), Mike Pack (Linebacker)
USAFootball.com
1999:
Honorable Mention – Christian Batcheller (Quarterback), Justin Holton (Offensive Line)
Champion
1993:
Second Team – Robert Hull (Defensive Line)
1992:
Second Team – Bob Ehret (Punter)
1991:
Third Team – John McCallum (Defensive End)