| 2010 | 14-5 | 2011 | 15-5 | |||
| Feb. 24 |
Salisbury | L, 4-10 |
Feb. 20 |
Mary Washington |
W, 18-17 |
|
| Feb. 27 |
St. Mary's (Md.) | W, 14-6 |
Feb. 24 |
Sewanee |
W, 21-13 |
|
| Mar. 2 |
Bridgewater | W, 20-4 |
Feb. 27 |
Stevenson |
W, 10-9 |
|
| Mar. 6 |
Franklin & Marshall |
L, 8-16 |
Mar. 5 |
Franklin & Marshall |
L, 8-11 |
|
| Mar. 9 |
Sweet Briar |
W, 21-1 |
Mar. 8 |
Hollins |
W, 21-0 |
|
| Mar. 13 |
Mary Washington | W, 16-10 |
Mar. 12 |
Salisbury |
L, 9-12 |
|
| Mar. 17 |
Cortland State |
L, 13-8 |
Mar. 16 |
Cortland State |
L, 7-8 |
|
| Mar. 20 |
Virginia Wesleyan |
W, 20-8 |
Mar. 19 |
Catholic |
L, 13-15 |
|
| Mar. 23 |
Union (N.Y.) |
L, 3-17 |
Mar. 24 |
Roanoke |
W, 17-10 |
|
| Mar. 29 |
Roanoke |
W, 9-7 |
Mar. 30 |
Sweet Briar |
W, 21-0 |
|
| Mar. 31 |
Hollins |
W, 22-2 |
Apr. 2 |
Virginia Wesleyan |
W, 19-10 |
|
| Apr. 3 |
Lynchburg | W, 11-5 |
Apr. 6 |
Bridgewater |
W, 20-7 |
|
| Apr. 7 |
Catholic |
W, 10-9 |
Apr. 17 |
Lynchburg |
W, 7-6 |
|
| Apr. 18 |
Randolph-Macon |
W, 9-8 |
Apr. 20 |
Guilford |
W, 19-6 |
|
| Apr. 21 |
Guilford | W, 20-6 |
Apr. 23 |
Randolph-Macon |
W, 18-8 |
|
| Apr. 28 |
Randolph-Macon* | W, 16-4 |
Apr. 28 |
Randolph |
W, 22-1 |
|
| May 1 |
Lynchburg* | W, 14-6 |
May 4 |
Virginia Wesleyan* |
W, 9-6 |
|
| May 8 |
Christopher Newport |
W, 16-7 |
May 8 |
Roanoke* |
W, 21-13 |
|
| May 12 | Elizabethtown^ |
L, 12-13 |
May 11 |
Christopher Newport^ |
W, 15-6 |
|
| May 14 |
Salisbury^ |
L, 12-13 |
||||
| *ODAC Tournament |
||||||
| ^NCAA Tournament | *ODAC Tournament |
|||||
| ^NCAA Tournament | ||||||
| 2012 | 15-5 | 2013 | 10-10 | |||
| Feb. 20 | Christopher Newport | W, 10-9 | Feb. 20 | St. Mary's (Md.) | L, 0-1 | |
| Feb. 25 | Stevenson | W, 10-8 | Feb. 23 | Christopher Newport | L, 8-9 | |
| Mar. 3 | Franklin & Marshall | L, 6-14 | Feb. 26 | Randolph | W, 16-5 | |
| Mar. 7 | Haverford | W, 14-12 | Mar. 2 | Franklin & Marshall | L, 5-13 | |
| Mar. 10 | Salisbury | L, 3-19 | Mar. 5 | Hollins | W, 21-1 | |
| Mar. 13 | Hollins | W, 22-0 | Mar. 9 | Salisbury | L, 5-15 | |
| Mar. 17 | Catholic | W, 11-10 | Mar. 13 | Roanoke | L, 12-13 2OT | |
| Mar. 21 | Roanoke | W, 12-8 | Mar. 16 | Virginia Wesleyan | W, 14-4 | |
| Mar. 24 | Mary Washington | L, 5-13 | Mar. 23 | Catholic | L, 9-11 | |
| Mar. 27 | Sweet Briar | W, 23-2 | Mar. 27 | Randolph-Macon | W, 13-7 | |
| Randolph | W, 21-2 | Mar. 30 | Lynchburg | W, 12-10 OT | ||
| Mar. 31 | Virginia Wesleyan | W, 16-5 | Apr. 3 | Shenandoah | L, 7-11 | |
| Apr. 4 | Bridgewater | W, 21-9 | Apr. 14 | Mary Washington | L, 7-14 | |
| Apr. 14 | Lynchburg | W, 8-6 | Apr. 17 | Bridgewater | W, 9-7 | |
| Apr. 18 | Guilford | W, 16-4 | Apr. 20 | Guilford | L, 6-11 | |
| Apr. 21 | Randolph-Macon | W, 19-7 | Apr. 21 | Sweet Briar | W, 12-3 | |
| Apr. 22 | Gettysburg | L, 4-10 | Apr. 24 | Lynchburg * | W, 13-9 | |
| May 2 | Guilford* | W, 18-10 | Apr. 27 | Guilford * | W, 14-13 | |
| May 6 | Roanoke* | W, 20-5 | May 4 | Shenandoah * | W, 11-8 | |
| May 9 | Mary Washington^ | L, 8-16 | May 8 | York (Pa.) ^ | L, 6-13 | |
| *ODAC Tournament | *ODAC Tournament | |||||
| ^NCAA Tournament | ^NCAA Tournament |
